While
every effort is made to ensure the accuracy of the contents of this site, users
should be aware that due to circumstances beyond our control, it may be
necessary to change the text of documents posted here and therefore no
responsibility will be accepted by the Toronto Transit Commission for
discrepancies which may occur between documents contained on this site and the
formal hardcopy versions presented to the Commission.
If it is necessary to rely on the accuracy of Commission documents the Office
of the General Secretary should be contacted at 393-3698 to obtain a certifed
copy. ONLY HARDCOPY RECORDS CERTIFIED BY THE GENERAL
SECRETARY WILL BE DEEMED TO BE OFFICIAL.
M I N U T E S
TORONTO TRANSIT
COMMISSION
Meeting No. 1878 Wednesday, January
31, 2007
A meeting of the Toronto Transit Commission was held
in the Council Chamber, Toronto City Hall, 100 Queen Street West, Toronto,
Ontario on Wednesday, January 31, 2007 commencing at 1:15 p.m.
A. Giambrone
(Chair), J. Mihevc (Vice-Chair), B. Saundercook, S. Hall, G. De Baeremaeker, M.
Thompson, P. Milczyn, S. Bussin and A. Perruzza (Commissioners), G. Webster
(Interim Chief General Manager), V. Rodo (General Manager – Executive & General Secretary), R. Cornacchia
(Acting General Manager – Operations), S. Ghaly (Acting Chief Project Manager,
Construction), B. Leck (General Counsel), A. Chocorlan (Manager - Materials
& Procurement), M. Roche (Chief Financial Officer), T. Andrews (Chief
Special Constable), S. Blakey (Executive Director - Human Resources), A. Smith
(Acting Chief Marketing Officer), M. Stambler (Manager – Service Planning), R.
Thacker (General Superintendent, Wheel-Trans), W. Buffett (Assistant General
Secretary) and F. Stanois (Co-ordinator - Secretariat Services) were present.
A. Giambrone was in the Chair.
______________________________________________
DECLARATION
OF INTEREST – MUNICIPAL CONFLICT OF INTEREST ACT
– NIL
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT THE COMMISSION APPROVE THE
MINUTES FROM MEETING NO. 1877 AND THAT THE CHAIR AND GENERAL SECRETARY BE
AUTHORIZED TO SIGN THE SAME.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
BUSINESS
ARISING OUT OF THE MINUTES
– NIL
COMMITTEE
OF THE WHOLE RESOLUTION
VICE-CHAIR
MIHEVC MOVED THAT THE COMMISSION MEET AS THE COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE ON TUESDAY,
FEBRUARY 27, 2007 AT 9:00 A.M., OR LATER, TO DEAL WITH LITIGATION OR POTENTIAL
LITIGATION MATTERS, LABOUR RELATIONS OR EMPLOYEE NEGOTIATIONS AND TO RECEIVE
ADVICE WHICH IS SUBJECT TO SOLICITOR-CLIENT PRIVILEGE.
THE
MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
DEPUTATIONS
a) Report No. 2b) - 2007 Wheel-Trans Operating Budget
Carol Anne Monet
Jose Rhodes
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE
DEPUTATIONS.
(SEE ITEM NO. 2B FOR MINUTE)
b) Report No. 2c) – 2007-2011 TTC Capital Program &
10-Year Capital Forecast
Councillor Janet
Davis
City of Toronto
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE
DEPUTATION.
(SEE ITEM NO. 2C FOR MINUTE)
c) Requests for Additional Periods of
Operation on the
32D Eglinton West Bus Route
The deputants in, consultation
with Chair Giambrone, agreed to defer their presentations until the February
2007 meeting, pending submission of a staff report on this matter.
CHAIR GIAMBRONE MOVED THAT THE COMMISSION
RECEIVE THE COMMUNICATION SUBMITTED BY COUNCILLOR NUNIZATA, AND REQUEST STAFF
TO REPORT BACK ON THIS REQUEST FOR SERVICE AT THE FEBRUARY 2007 COMMISSION
MEETING.
THE MOTION BY CHAIR GIAMBRONE CARRIED.
d) Report 5h) - 67 Pharmacy – Through Service at
Sheppard Avenue
Councillor Norm
Kelly
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE
DEPUTATION.
(SEE REPORT 5H FOR MINUTE)
e) Signage and Wayfinding at the TTC
Joe Clark
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE
DEPUTATION.
COMMISSIONER MILCZYN MOVED THAT STAFF BE
REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK ON THE ISSUES RAISED IN MR. CLARK’S DEPUTATION,
INCLUDING AN UPDATE ON THE COMPREHENSIVE STUDY PREVIOUSLY UNDERTAKEN BY THE TTC
ON SIGNAGE AND WAYFINDING.
THE MOTION BY COMMISSIONER MILCZYN CARRIED.
COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA MOVED THAT STAFF BE
REQUESTED TO INCLUDE IN THEIR REPORT THE RATIONALE FOR NO LONGER USING
ESCALATOR SIGNAGE INDICATING “STAND RIGHT – WALK LEFT”.
THE MOTION BY COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA CARRIED.
CHAIR GIAMBRONE MOVED THAT STAFF BE REQUESTED
TO DISTRIBUTE A COPY OF MR. CLARK’S SUBMISSION TO EACH COMMISSIONER.
THE MOTION BY CHAIR GIAMBRONE CARRIED.
f) Report 3l – Procurement Authorization
Wheelchair
Accessible Taxi Service – Pilot Project
Mohammed Hakim Zadah
ABC Taxi
Barry Horosko
Bratty and Partners
(On behalf of
Associated Toronto Taxicab Co-operative Limited)
Mehari Abera
Prince Darquah
Shiddo Mohamud
Ikram Freed
Stan Makuch
Cassels Brock
Blackwell
(On behalf of
Accessible Transportation Association of Ontario)
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE DEPUTATIONS.
(SEE REPORT 3L FOR MINUTE)
NOTICE
OF MOTIONS -
NIL
1. PRESENTATIONS
a) Presentation to former TTC Chair
Howard Moscoe
On behalf of the
Commission and its employees, G. Webster, Interim Chief General Manager and
Chair Giambrone thanked Councillor Moscoe for his valued contribution to the
Toronto Transit Commission over the past fourteen years.
b) Cleanliness
Audit of Stations and Vehicles
The Commission had
before it a memorandum dated January 31, 2007 from G. Webster, Interim Chief
General Manager entitled, “Presentation – Cleanliness Audit of Stations and
Vehicles.”
THE COMMISSION DEFERRED THE PRESENTATION UNTIL
ITS NEXT MEETING.
CHAIR GIAMBRONE MOVED THAT STAFF BE REQUESTED
TO REPORT BACK IN THREE MONTHS AND THEN AGAIN IN SIX MONTHS ON THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF THE CLEANLINESS EFFORTS, AND SPECIFICALLY COMMENT ON THE
FOLLOWING:
·
COST
TO REPLACE METAL CEILING SLATS;
·
CO-ORDINATION
BETWEEN STATION AND TUNNEL CLEANING IN STATION AREAS AND THE IMPACT OF ANOTHER
CREW OF TRACK AND STRUCTURE EMPLOYEES TO IMPROVE THE CYCLE OF STATION TUNNEL
RELATED CLEANING; AND
·
ADDITIONAL
WORK REQUIRED TO ADDRESS SUPERFICIAL OR APPEARANCE MAINTENANCE WORK ESPECIALLY
ON THE CEILINGS.
THE MOTION BY CHAIR GIAMBRONE CARRIED.
2. BUDGET
MATTERS
a) 2007 TTC
Operating Budget
M. Stambler,
Manager, Service Planning gave a PowerPoint presentation entitled, “TTC Budgets
and City-Building”.
M.Roche, Chief
Financial Officer gave an overhead slide presentation entitled, “2007 TTC
Operating Budget Overview”.
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE
PRESENTATIONS FOR INFORMATION.
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT THE COMMISSION
APPROVE THE FOLLOWING STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS, IN PRINCIPLE ONLY, AND THAT THE
TTC AND CITY BUDGET COMMITTEES BE REQUESTED TO COME FORWARD WITH OPTIONS TO
BALANCE THE 2007 TTC OPERATING BUDGET:
“IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT THE
COMMISSION:
1. APPROVE THE 2007 TTC OPERATING BUDGET
(SUMMARIZED IN EXHIBIT 1 – REVISED) AS DESCRIBED IN THIS REPORT AND THE
FOLLOWING ACCOMPANYING REPORTS:
·
TTC
2007 OPERATING BUDGET OVERVIEW
·
TTC
2007 DEPARTMENTAL GOALS & OBJECTIVES
·
TTC
2007 ORGANIZATION CHARTS
·
TTC
2007 DETAILED OPERATING BUDGET (BLUE BOOK)
2. CONSIDER THIS REPORT IN CONCERT WITH:
A) THE 2007 WHEEL-TRANS OPERATING BUDGET
B) THE
2007-2011 CAPITAL PROGRAM AND 10-YEAR CAPITAL FORECAST
3. NOTE THAT BASED ON FLAT-LINED CITY OF
TORONTO OPERATING SUBSIDY LEVELS, THE TTC 2007 OPERATING BUDGET INCLUDES A BASE
BUDGET SHORTFALL OF $34 MILLION AS SUMMARIZED BELOW:
EXPENDITURES $1,090.9 MILLION
REVENUES* 811.1 MILLION
SUBSIDY NEEDED 297.8 MILLION
ESTIMATED CITY OPERATING SUBSIDY 246.3 MILLION
SHORTFALL $
33.5 MILLION
* BASED ON CURRENT FARE STRUCTURE.
4. APPROVE THE CONTRIBUTION OF ANY 2006 NET
OPERATING SURPLUS TO THE TTC STABILIZATION RESERVE FUND FOR UTILIZATION AGAINST
THE 2007 TTC OPERATING BUDGET SHORTFALL.
5. FORWARD THIS REPORT TO THE CITY OF TORONTO
REQUESTING APPROVAL OF:
A) THE CITY’S 2007 TRANSIT OPERATING SUBSIDY
TO THE TTC;
B) CONFIRMATION OF THE ESTABLISHMENT OF AN
ADDITIONAL LONG-TERM SUBSIDY RECEIVABLE IN THE AMOUNT OF $17.6 MILLION TO COVER
POST-RETIREMENT BENEFIT NON-CASH EXPENSES CONSISTENT WITH PREVIOUS ACCOUNTING
TREATMENT APPROVED BY COUNCIL; AND
C) THE CONTRIBUTION OF ANY 2006 NET OPERATING
SURPLUS TO THE TTC STABILIZATION RESERVE FUND FOR UTILIZATION AGAINST THE 2007
TTC OPERATING BUDGET SHORTFALL.
6. FORWARD THIS REPORT TO THE ONTARIO MINISTER
OF TRANSPORTATION, THE HONOURABLE DONNA CANSFIELD, THE ONTARIO MINISTER OF
PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE RENEWAL, THE HONOURABLE DAVID CAPLAN, AND TO THE ONTARIO
MINISTER OF FINANCE, THE HONOURABLE GREGORY SORBARA, FOR INFORMATION.
7. FORWARD THIS REPORT TO THE FEDERAL MINISTER
OF TRANSPORT, INFRASTRUCTURE AND COMMUNITIES, THE HONOURABLE LAWRENCE CANNON,
FOR INFORMATION.
8. FORWARD THIS REPORT TO ROB MCISAAC, CHAIR
OF THE GREATER TORONTO TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY, FOR INFORMATION.”
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
CHAIR GIAMBRONE MOVED THE FOLLOWING:
1. THAT STAFF BE REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK TO
THE TTC PROPERTY RE-USE & REVITALIZATION COMMITTEE ON THE ADDITIONAL
RESOURCES REQUIRED TO ACTIVELY PURSUE PROPERTY DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITIES
ASSOCIATED WITH TTC/CITY PROPERTIES, SPECIFICALLY COMMENTING ON THE USE OF
CONTRACT EMPLOYEES FOR A SPECIFIED PERIOD AND CONSIDER THIS DURING THE
RESOLUTION OF THE 2007 OPERATING BUDGET.
2. THAT STAFF BE REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK TO
THE COMMISSION ON OPPORTUNITIES TO REDUCE HYDRO EXPENSES AND CONSIDER AN
AMENDMENT TO THE 2007 OPERATING BUDGET TO IDENTIFY THESE SAVINGS ALONG WITH ANY
RESOURCES NECESSARY TO ACHIEVE THOSE OBJECTIVES; AND FURTHER THAT STAFF ALSO
REPORT BACK ON IDENTIFYING EXISTING STAFF TO ACT AS THE KEY POINT PERSON ON
THESE ENVIRONMENTAL FILES.
3. THAT THE COMMISSION APPROVE ALLOCATING
$250,000 FROM HYDRO SAVINGS TO PROVIDE MORE SURFACE AND SUBWAY SERVICE DURING
2007 NUIT BLANCHE AND NEW YEARS EVE, AND THAT STAFF REPORT BACK WITH A SERVICE
DESIGN.
4. THAT THE 2007 TTC OPERATING BUDGET BE
AMENDED TO ADD THREE SOLICITORS, ONE LEGAL ASSISTANT AND ONE LEGAL CLERK FOR A
GROSS COST OF $499,200 AND THAT THE BUDGET FOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS BE REDUCED BY AN
EQUAL AMOUNT FOR A NET BUDGET IMPACT OF NIL.
THE MOTIONS BY CHAIR GIAMBRONE CARRIED.
THE COMMISSION APPROVED THE STAFF REPORT, AS
AMENDED.
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT TTC STAFF AND
COMMISSIONERS EXPLORE USING THE PRESENTATION ENTITLED, “TTC BUDGETS AND
CITY-BUILDING” AS THE BASIS OF A PUBLIC CONSULTATION AND DISCUSSION DOCUMENT ON
THE FUTURE OF THE TTC IN THE CITY OF TORONTO.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
b) 2007
Wheel-Trans Operating Budget
R. Thacker, General
Superintendent, Wheel-Trans gave a PowerPoint presentation entitled,
“Wheel-Trans Operations 2007 Budget Presentation”.
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE
PRESENTATION FOR INFORMATION.
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT THE COMMISSION
APPROVE THE FOLLOWING STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS, IN PRINCIPLE ONLY, AND THAT THE
TTC AND CITY BUDGET COMMITTEES BE REQUESTED TO COME FORWARD WITH OPTIONS TO
BALANCE THE 2007 WHEEL-TRANS OPERATING BUDGET:
“IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT THE
COMMISSION APPROVE:
1. THE 2007 WHEEL-TRANS OPERATING BUDGET
(SUMMARIZED IN APPENDIX A) AS DESCRIBED IN THIS REPORT AND THE FOLLOWING
ACCOMPANYING REPORTS:
·
2007
WHEEL-TRANS OPERATING BUDGET OVERVIEW
·
2007
WHEEL-TRANS DETAILED OPERATING BUDGET (BLUE BOOK)
·
2007
TTC DEPARTMENTAL GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
·
2007
TTC ORGANIZATION CHARTS
2. CONSIDER THIS REPORT IN CONCERT WITH:
A) THE 2007 TTC OPERATING BUDGET
B) THE 2007-2011 CAPITAL PROGRAM AND 10-YEAR
CAPITAL FORECAST
3. NOTE THAT BASED ON FLAT-LINED CITY OF
TORONTO OPERATING SUBSIDY LEVELS, THE PROPOSED WHEEL-TRANS OPERATING BUDGET
INCLUDES A BASE BUDGET SHORTFALL OF $5.6 MILLION AS SUMMARIZED BELOW:
EXPENDITURES* $68.7 MILLION
REVENUES** 3.2 MILLION
SUBSIDY NEEDED $65.5 MILLION
ESTIMATED CITY OPERATING SUBSIDY 59.9 MILLION (2006 BUDGET)
SHORTFALL
$ 5.6 MILLION
* NET
OF POST-RETIREMENT BENEFIT NON-CASH EXPENSES.
** BASED ON CURRENT FARE STRUCTURE.
4. NOTE THAT POST-RETIREMENT BENEFIT NON-CASH
EXPENSES, IN THE AMOUNT OF $830,000, ARE NOT INCLUDED IN THE NET OPERATING
SUBSIDY REQUIREMENT AS THESE EXPENDITURES WILL BE FINANCED THROUGH A LONG-TERM
SUBSIDY RECEIVABLE FROM THE CITY;
5. THE
WHEEL-TRANS SERVICE PLAN WHICH ENCOMPASSES THE FOLLOWING KEY FACTORS:
Ø
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA AND
APPLICATION PROCESS REMAIN UNCHANGED;
Ø
REGISTRANT BASE INCREASING BY 14%
TO 51,000;
Ø
TRIP DEMAND INCREASING BY 7.8% TO
2,099,200;
Ø
UNACCOMMODATED RATE REMAINING AT
2%;
Ø
TRIPS PROVIDED BY ACCESSIBLE
VEHICLES REMAINING AT 88%;
Ø
TRIPS INCREASING TO 2,186,200
(INCLUDES COMMUNITY BUS);
Ø
FURTHER INTEGRATION WITH THE
CONVENTIONAL TRANSIT SYSTEM;
Ø
COMMUNITY BUS ROUTES INCREASE
FROM FIVE (5) TO SIX (6);
Ø
IMPLEMENTATION OF NEW ACCESSIBLE
AND SEDAN TAXI CONTRACTS;
Ø
WORKFORCE INCREASING BY 43 TO A
YEAR-END COMPLEMENT OF 459.
6. FORWARD THIS
REPORT TO THE CITY OF TORONTO REQUESTING APPROVAL OF:
A) THE CITY’S
2007 OPERATING SUBSIDY FOR THE WHEEL-TRANS OPERATION; AND
B) CONFIRMATION
OF THE ESTABLISHMENT OF AN ADDITIONAL RECEIVABLE IN THE AMOUNT OF $830,000 TO
COVER POST-RETIREMENT BENEFIT NON-CASH EXPENSES;
7. FORWARD THIS
REPORT TO THE TTC’S ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON ACCESSIBLE TRANSPORTATION (ACAT) FOR
INFORMATION;
8. FORWARD THIS
REPORT TO THE ONTARIO MINISTRY OF TRANSPORTATION, THE HONOURABLE DONNA
CANSFIELD, THE ONTARIO MINISTRY OF PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE RENEWAL, THE
HONOURABLE DAVID CAPLAN, AND THE ONTARIO MINISTRY OF FINANCE, THE HONOURABLE
GREG SORBARA FOR INFORMATION; AND
9. FORWARD THIS
REPORT TO ROB MCISAAC, CHAIR OF THE GREATER TORONTO TRANSIT TRANSPORTATION
AUTHORITY, FOR INFORMATION.”
THE
MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
THE COMMISSION
APPROVED THE STAFF REPORT, AS AMENDED.
COMMISSIONER
THOMPSON MOVED THAT STAFF BE REQUESTED TO REPORT ON THE FOLLOWING:
1. MAKING THE
LAWRENCE 54 BUS ROUTE AN ACCESSIBLE ROUTE; AND
2. MAKING THE
LAWRENCE RT STATION AN ACCESSIBLE STATION, INCLUDING THE POSSIBILITY OF MAKING
ALL RT STATIONS ACCESSIBLE WHEN THE SCARBOROUGH RT IS UPGRADED.
THE MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER THOMPSON CARRIED.
COMMISSIONER
HALL MOVED THAT STAFF BE REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK ON THE STATUS OF A COMMITMENT
MADE BY THE COMMISSION TO PROVIDE ACCESSIBLE SERVICE ON THE 41 KEELE, 89 WESTON
AND 96 WILSON BUS ROUTES.
THE MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER HALL CARRIED.
c) 2007-2011 TTC Capital Program and
10-Year Capital Forecast
M. Roche, Chief Financial Officer gave an
overhead slide presentation entitled, “TTC’s 2007-2011 Capital Program”.
R. Cornacchia, Acting General Manager,
Operations gave an overhead slide presentation entitled, “Streetcar Fleet
Options – Recommended 2007-2011 Capital Budget”.
THE
COMMISSION RECEIVED THE PRESENTATIONS FOR INFORMATION.
VICE-CHAIR
MIHEVC MOVED THAT THE COMMISSION APPROVE THE FOLLOWING STAFF RECOMMENDATIONS,
IN PRINCIPLE ONLY, AND THAT THE TTC AND CITY BUDGET COMMITTEES COME FORWARD
WITH APPROPRIATE ADJUSTMENTS TO THE BUDGET:
“IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT THE COMMISSION:
1 A) APPROVE THE 2007 CAPITAL
PROGRAM IN THE AMOUNT OF $747.1 MILLION AS DESCRIBED IN THIS REPORT (AND
SUMMARIZED IN APPENDIX A) AND THE ACCOMPANYING DOCUMENTS:
·
TTC
2007-2011 CAPITAL PROGRAM OVERVIEW
·
TTC
2007-2011 CAPITAL PROGRAM (BLUE BOOKS)
B)
APPROVE THE 2007-2011 CAPITAL PROGRAM IN THE AMOUNT OF $4.035 BILLION AS
OUTLINED IN THIS REPORT AND THE ACCOMPANYING DOCUMENTS.
C)
APPROVE THE 10-YEAR CAPITAL FORECAST IN THE AMOUNT OF $6.874 BILLION AS SHOWN
IN THIS REPORT AND THE ACCOMPANYING DOCUMENTS.
2. CONFIRM ITS PREVIOUS
DIRECTION AND AMEND THE 2007-2011 CAPITAL PROGRAM BY ADDING $9.9 MILLION FOR
2007 AND $79.1 MILLION FOR THE FIVE YEARS 2007-2011 AS OUTLINED IN PART 6
(APPROVED BUDGET AMENDMENTS) OF THIS REPORT AND AS FOLLOWS:

3. CONSIDER ADDITIONAL
AMENDMENTS TO THE 2007-2011 CAPITAL PROGRAM AS OUTLINED IN PART 7 (POTENTIAL
BUDGET AMENDMENTS) OF THIS REPORT.
4. CONSIDER THIS REPORT IN
CONCERT WITH THE FOLLOWING:
(a)
THE
TTC 2007 OPERATING BUDGET
(b)
THE
TTC 2007 WHEEL-TRANS OPERATING BUDGET
(c)
THE
TTC 2007 DEPARTMENTAL GOALS AND OBJECTIVES
(d)
THE
TTC 2007 ORGANIZATION CHARTS
5. FORWARD THIS REPORT TO THE
CITY OF TORONTO FOR COUNCIL APPROVAL OF THE 2007 CAPITAL PROGRAM IN THE AMOUNT
OF $757.0 MILLION AND $4,114.4 BILLION FOR THE 2007-2011 CAPITAL PROGRAM (AS
AMENDED PER RECOMMENDATION 2 ABOVE) AND APPROVAL OF THE 10 YEAR FORECAST.
6. FORWARD THIS REPORT TO THE
ONTARIO MINISTER OF TRANSPORTATION, THE HONOURABLE DONNA CANSFIELD, THE ONTARIO
MINISTER OF PUBLIC INFRASTRUCTURE RENEWAL, THE HONOURABLE DAVID CAPLAN, AND TO
THE ONTARIO MINISTER OF FINANCE, THE HONOURABLE GREGORY SORBARA, FOR
INFORMATION.
7. FORWARD THIS REPORT TO THE FEDERAL
MINISTER OF TRANSPORT, INFRASTRUCTURE AND COMMUNITIES, THE HONOURABLE LAWRENCE
CANNON, FOR INFORMATION.
8. FORWARD THIS REPORT TO ROB MCISAAC, CHAIR
OF THE GREATER TORONTO TRANSPORTATION AUTHORITY, FOR INFORMATION.”
VICE-CHAIR
MIHEVC MOVED THE FOLLOWING:
1. ADD $0.75
MILLION TO THE 2007 CAPITAL BUDGET FOR VICTORIA PARK – ENHANCEMENTS FOR DESIGN
COSTS;
2. ADD $6.0
MILLION TO THE 2008-2011 CAPITAL PROGRAM FOR VICTORIA PARK – ENHANCEMENTS, FOR
A TOTAL OF $8.4 MILLION; THAT STAFF REPORT BACK WITH A MORE DETAILED COSTING
AND PHASING OF THE PROJECT FOR INCLUSION IN THE 2008-2012 CAPITAL PROGRAM, AND
THAT A COPY OF THE REPORT BE FORWARDED TO THE TTC PROPERTY RE-USE &
REVITALIZATION COMMITTEE;
3. THE
STREETCAR FLEET PLAN BE APPROVED AS DESCRIBED IN OPTION 4B THEREBY SAVING
$410.0 MILLION OVER THE 2007-2011 PERIOD;
4. ADD $1.0
MILLION FOR STATION MODERNIZATION;
5. ADD $ 0.3
MILLION NET FOR UNIVERSITY RENAISSANCE – ST. PATRICK STATION
6. ADD $3.0
MILLION FOR ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENTS; AND
7. ADD $0.4
MILLION FOR PARK LAWN LOOP REPLACEMENT.
THE MOTION BY
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
COMMISSIONER
HALL MOVED THE FOLLOWING:
1. INCREASE THE
ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT BUDGET TO INCLUDE WITHIN THE MAYOR’S PLATFORM $250,000
IN 2007 AND A COMMITMENT OF $250,000 IN 2008 FOR A NORTH ETOBICOKE RAPID
TRANSIT ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT, AS WELL AS THE FINCH HYDRO CORRIDOR BETWEEN
DUFFERIN STREET AND YONGE STREET; AND FURTHER THAT STAFF SEEK FUNDING FROM
DEVELOPMENT CHARGES TO LIMIT DEBT EXPOSURE.
THE MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER HALL CARRIED.
COMMISSIONER
MILCZYN MOVED THE FOLLOWING:
1. APPROVE $0.5
MILLION TO ALLOW DEVELOPMENT TO BEGIN ON THREE CUSTOMER INFORMATION SYSTEMS,
NAMELY NEXT BUS, TRIP PLANNER AND E-COMMERCE, PLUS REPORT BACK IN MARCH ON
FURTHER 2007 COSTS PLUS FUTURE COSTS TO BEGIN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THESE
SYSTEMS.
2. THAT STAFF
BE REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK ON THE COST OF UPDATING THE BLOOR-DANFORTH
(SHERWAY) WESTERLY SUBWAY EXTENSION ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT SO AS TO DETERMINE
THE REQUIREMENTS FOR AN EXTENSION TO A NEW EAST MALL SUBWAY STATION; AND THAT
SUCH REPORT OUTLINE THE IMPACT ON THE 2007 AND FUTURE CAPITAL BUDGETS.
THE MOTION BY
COMMISSIONER MILCZYN CARRIED.
THE COMMISSION
APPROVED THE STAFF REPORT, AS AMENDED.
3. PROCUREMENT
MATTERS
a) Procurement
Authorization Arrow Road
Garage Air
Piping Upgrades Contract V1-10
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the award of Contract V1-10, Arrow Road Garage,
Air Piping Upgrades to Servocraft Limited in the amount of $250,950.00.
APPROVED
b) Procurement Authorization
Consultant
Design Services Contract G85-226
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the award of Consultant Design Services contracts
to the following companies in the amounts listed below for a three year period
commencing February 1, 2007 to January 31, 2010 in the total upset limit amount
of $10,000,000:
Package One: Electrical/Mechanical
Design Services
·
$1,250,000 to Totten Sims Hubicki Associates (1997)
Limited;
·
$1,250,000 to URS Architects & Engineers Canada Inc.;
Package Two:
Multi-Discipline Design Services
·
$2,500,000 to Totten Sims Hubicki Associates (1997)
Limited;
·
$2,500,000 to Marshall Macklin Monaghan Ltd.;
·
$2,500,000 to Giffels Associates limited.
APPROVED
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT STAFF BE
REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK WITH A COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS ON PROVIDING SOME OF
THESE SERVICES INTERNALLY.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
c) Procurement
Authorization Design
Services
Wheel-Trans Facility – Renewal
Program Contract
WR85-7 Contract Amendment 1
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize Contract Amendment No. 1 to Richard Stevens
Architect Ltd. in the amount of $215,000, for Design Services – Wheel-Trans
Facility – Renewal Program, for a total contract amount of $635,000.
APPROVED
d) Procurement Authorization Lakeshore
Garage – Parking
Deck Rehabilitation Contract WT1-18
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the award of a contract to Alliance Restoration
Ltd. (Alliance) in the amount of $471,064.00 for Contract WT1-18, Lakeshore
Garage – Parking Deck Rehabilitation.
APPROVED
e) Procurement
Authorization Project Management Contract G85-211
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the release of $3,067,000 for the period of March
1, 2007 to February 29, 2008 bringing the total released amount up to
$10,067,000 for Contract G85-211 Project Management with Delcan Corporation,
Hatch Mott MacDonald Ltd., UMA Engineering Ltd. (DHU) Joint Venture.
APPROVED
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT STAFF BE
REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK WITH A COST-BENEFIT ANALYSIS ON PROVIDING SOME OF
THESE SERVICES INTERNALLY.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
f) Procurement Authorization Testing
& Inspection
Services –
Triennial Contract Contract G85-225
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the award of contracts to the following firms in
the upset limit amounts listed below for Testing and Inspection Services for a
three-year period, from notification of contract awards:
1. Davroc Testing
Laboratories Inc. $1,000,000.00
2. DBA Engineering
Ltd. $1,000,000.00
for a total upset
limit of $2,000,000.00.
APPROVED
g) Procurement
Authorization – Supply of Hand and Cutting Tools
It is recommended
that the Commission approve the issuance of a purchase order for the supply of
hand and cutting tools to Hansler Smith Ltd. in the upset limit of $7,600,000
for a five year period from March 1, 2007 to February 29, 2012.
APPROVED
h) Procurement
Authorization Contract Amendment
C31D01836-19
Speed Control System – Additional Training
It is recommended that
the Commission approve the issuance of Contract Amendment No. 19 to Alcatel
Canada Inc. (Alcatel), in the total amount of $229,442.00 for the provision of
additional training.
APPROVED
i) Procurement
Authorization – Preventive
Maintenance
Program for Underground Storage Tank Systems
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the award of a contract to Service/Stat
Maintenance Limited, in the total upset limit of $245,000, for preventive
maintenance and repairs to the Commission’s underground storage tank systems
for the period of February 1, 2007 to December 31, 2009.
APPROVED
j) Procurement
Authorization – Supply and Installation of Lighting
Poles – Yonge
Subway Open Cut from Bloor to Summerhill Stations
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the award of a contract to Dig-Con International
Limited in the amount of $333,456.92 for the supply and installation of
lighting poles for the Yonge Subway open cut area from Bloor to Summerhill
Stations.
APPROVED
k) Procurement Authorization – TTC Portion
of Cleaning
and Coating on
Queen Street Viaduct Over the Don Valley
It is recommended
that the Commission approve issuing a purchase order in the upset limit amount
of $453,184.81, to the City of Toronto – Department of Works and Emergency
Services, for the Commission’s portion of the cost for the cleaning and coating
of structural steel work on the Queen Street Viaduct over the Don Valley.
APPROVED
l) Procurement Authorization –
Wheelchair
Accessible Taxi Service – Pilot Project
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT
THE COMMISSION RECESS TO MEET IN-CAMERA TO RECEIVE ADVICE RELATING TO
LITIGATION OR POTENTIAL LITIGATION.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
The Commission resumed in public session.
COMMISSIONER MILCZYN MOVED
THAT THE COMMISSION APPROVE THE STAFF RECOMMENDATION EMBODIED IN THE REPORT.
COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA MOVED AN AMENDMENT TO
COMMISSIONER MILCZYN’S MOTION BY CHANGING THE END DATE FROM JUNE 30, 2007 TO
OCTOBER 30, 2007 FOR BOTH MOTION TAXI AND ASSOCIATED TORONTO TAXI CAB
CO-OPERATIVE LIMITED.
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT THE MATTER BE
DEFERRED FOR ONE MONTH TO ALLOW FOR AN INDEPENDENT LEGAL OPINION TO BE
RECEIVED.
CHAIR GIAMBRONE CALLED FOR A VOTE ON
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC’S DEFERRAL MOTION.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA MOVED THAT THE
COMMISSION SET ASIDE A DAY TO DEAL WITH THIS ISSUE SEPARATE FROM A REGULAR
COMMISSION MEETING.
THE MOTION BY COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA LOST.
m) Procurement
Authorization – Supply and Install One Bus Simulator
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize:
1. The award of a
contract to FAAC Incorporated in the amount of $608,000.00 for the manufacture,
delivery, installation and commissioning of a bus simulator; and
2. Authorize funds
in the amount of $85,120.00 that will be paid directly by the Commission for
GST in the amount of $36,480.00 and PST in the amount of $48,640.00, bringing
the total authorization to $693,120.00.
APPROVED
n) Procurement Authorization for Dry
Cleaning
of Uniform
Garments for a Three Year Period
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the award of a contract to Dove Corporation in
the upset amount of $3,258,000 for a three year period for the provision of dry
cleaning services.
APPROVED
o) Procurement Authorization for the
Supply of Pest Control Services
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT
THIS MATTER BE DEFERRED ONE MONTH AND THAT STAFF BE REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK ON
THE INCLUSION OF CRITERIA IN THE CONTRACT THAT WOULD REQUIRE ENVIRONMENTALLY
FRIENDLY PEST CONTROL METHODS.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT STAFF BE
AUTHORIZED TO EXTEND THE CURRENT PEST CONTROL SERVICES CONTRACT TO ALLOW FOR
THE ABOVE DEFERRAL AND REPORT REQUEST.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
p) Purchase of T1
Door Lock Assemblies
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the issuance of a purchase order to Vapor Rail
Incorporated in the amount of $230,679.00 including applicable taxes for 300
lock assemblies that will be used for the Commission’s T1 door system 10 year
overhaul program.
APPROVED
q) Purchase of
Rail Enclosures
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize the award of three-year inventory supply
contracts for the supply of rail enclosures to the following companies for the
period from February 2007 to January 2010:
·
Iron Horse Engineering for $332,000 including applicable
taxes.
·
Polycorp Limited for $2,500,000 including applicable taxes.
APPROVED
4. PROCUREMENT
AUTHORIZATION AMENDMENTS
a) Purchase Order
Amendment Authority Arrow Road and
Wilson Bus
Garages Overhead Speed Doors Contract G60-154
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize an amendment in the amount of $239,522.63 to
428686 Ontario Inc. o/b as Superior Door & Gate Systems, bringing the total
value to $907,202.63 from $667,680.00 for Contract G60-154 to include
replacement of 4 additional overhead speed doors at the Wilson and Arrow Road
Bus Garages.
APPROVED
b) Procurement
Authorization – Purchase Order
Amendment for
the Supply of Miscellaneous Hardware
It is recommended
that the Commission approve the issuance of a purchase order amendment to
Hengab Investments Ltd. (New Canadian Lumber) to increase the contract by
$120,000 to a total upset limit of $511,000.
APPROVED
c) Procurement
Authorization – Purchase Order
Amendment for
the Supply of Subway Car Cleaners
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize a purchase order amendment to extend the contract
with Johnson Diversey for the supply of subway car cleaners to March 31, 2007
and to increase the total upset limit amount by $100,000 to $637,500.
APPROVED
5. OTHER
BUSINESS
a) Environmental
Assessments for Transit Projects in the
Eastern
Waterfront – Procurement Authorization Contract Amendment
It is recommended
that the Commission authorize a contract amendment in the amount of $202,000 to
McCormick Rankin Corporation for the completion of environmental assessment
studies in the East Bayfront and West Don Lands study areas, increasing the
total upset limit contract amount from $1,000,000 to $1,202,000.
APPROVED
b) Summary of
Authorized Expenditures between $100,000 to
$200,000 for the
Period November 1, 2006 to November 30, 2006
It is recommended
that the Commission receive this report for information. It lists expenditures ($100,000 up to
$200,000) for the period November 1, 2006 to November 30, 2006, which were
approved by the Interim Chief General Manager.
RECEIVED
c) Waterfront West
Streetcars
Environmental
Assessment – Terms of Reference
It is recommended
that the Commission:
1. Receive this
report for information and authorize the submission of the Terms of Reference
(ToR) for the Waterfront West Streetcars Environmental Assessment (EA) for the
section from Dufferin Street to Roncesvalles Avenue to the Ministry of the
Environment (MOE) for approval.
2. Forward this report
to Toronto City Council through the Planning and Growth Management Committee
for approval prior to submission to the MOE.
APPROVED
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT STAFF BE
REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK ON THE OPTIONS TO IMPROVE PUBLIC TRANSIT INCLUDING THE
FEASIBILITY OF A BUS RAPID TRANSIT LINE ON DUFFERIN STREET ONCE THE DUFFERIN
JOG IS ELIMINATED.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
d) Declaration for Surplus – 230 Buses
It is recommended
that the Commission approve the declaration for surplus for the purpose of
selling or donating 230 surplus buses throughout 2007.
APPROVED
Commissioner Hall requested that staff provide
the new Commissioners with the procedure for the donation of buses to
non-profit organizations.
e) TTC Procedural
By-Law for Commission Meetings
COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA MOVED
THAT THIS MATTER BE REFERRED BACK TO STAFF FOR REVIEW AND POSSIBLE MODIFICATION
OF “ARTICLE VIII - ADDING NEW BUSINESS”,
SO THAT THE SECTIONS UNDER ARTICLE VIII ARE LESS RESTRICTIVE TO THE MEMBERS IN
BRINGING ISSUES FORWARD TO THE COMMISSION FOR CONSIDERATION.
THE MOTION BY COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA CARRIED.
f) 2007
Commission Meeting Schedule
COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA MOVED
THAT THE COMMISSION APPROVE THE STAFF RECOMMENDATION EMBODIED IN THE REPORT,
SUBJECT TO CHANGING THE MAY 16, 2007 DATE TO MAY 8, 2007.
THE MOTION BY COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA CARRIED.
COMMISSIONER PERRUZZA MOVED THAT STAFF
INVESTIGATE POSSIBLE ALTERNATE DATES FOR THE AUGUST 29, 2007 MEETING, INCLUDING
A REVIEW OF WHETHER THE DATES APPROVED CONFLICT WITH ANY FCM MEETINGS.
THE MOTION BY COMMISSION PERRUZZA CARRIED.
g) REPORT WITHDRAWN AS PER AGENDA.
h) 67 PHARMACY –
Through Service at Sheppard Avenue
It is recommended
that the Commission:
1. Receive this
report, noting that a re-instatement of the former 67B PHARMACY (Victoria Park
Station-Steeles) through service at Sheppard Avenue is not recommended, as it
would make service worse, overall, for customers; and
2. Forward this
report to Councillor Norm Kelly.
APPROVED
i) Accessible
Transit Services Plan – 2006 Status Report
It is recommended
that the Commission:
1. Receive this
report for information noting that:
·
The attached report describes the status of the TTC’s
current activities to improve the accessibility of TTC facilities and
services. It is the third annual update
of the more-comprehensive Accessible Transit Services Plan – Year-End 2003
Status Report, which was received by the Commission in February 2004;
·
The report fulfils provincially-legislated requirements for
an annual documentation of the TTC’s accessibility plans and major initiatives;
·
The new Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act,
2005 (AODA) requires that all transit services and facilities be accessible by
2025. The TTC’s current plans, as
outlined in the attached report, will meet or exceed this goal;
·
All the TTC’s accessible transit service plans and updates
are available on the TTC’s web site so the public can see the progress being
made each year towards the TTC’s accessibility goals; and
2. Forward this
report to the City of Toronto, the Ontario Ministries of Community and Social
Services, Transportation, and Public Infrastructure Renewal, the Ontario Human
Rights Commission, and the Greater Toronto Transportation Authority.
APPROVED
j) 29 DUFFERIN Bus Route – Service to
Exhibition Loop
It is recommended
that the Commission:
1. Receive this
report for information, noting that, as directed by the Commission at its
meeting of September 20, 2006, staff plan to extend the 29 DUFFERIN bus route
into Exhibition Place to coincide with the opening of the new BMO Field soccer
stadium. The trial service:
·
Will operate via an on-street routing on Saskatchewan Road,
Manitoba Drive, and Canada Boulevard to a cul-de-sac north-west of Princes’
Gates, on a trial basis, with every second 29 DUFFERIN bus operating on the
extended routing;
·
Will operate on event days at the new stadium between April
28, 2007 and May 12, 2007, and on a full-time basis commencing May 13, 2007
·
Will provide good connections with the existing streetcar
and GO Transit services at Exhibition Loop; does not require physical changes
to Exhibition Loop to provide bus access from the west; will have similar
additional operating costs to a service to Exhibition Loop alone; will allow
for the continuation of improved bus service to Ontario Place during the summer
months as has been operated for many years; and will avoid conflict with the
planned track reconstruction in the Exhibition Loop this spring;
·
Will require that existing resources be reallocated from
the major portion of the 29 DUFFERIN route, and elsewhere in the TTC system, to
accommodate the extension; and
2. Forward this
report to Deputy Mayor Pantalone, Councillors Augimeri, Moscoe, Palacio, and
Perks, to Exhibition Place, Ontario Place, GO Transit, and to the Greater
Toronto Transportation Authority.
APPROVED
k) Service to New McNicoll/Kennedy
Loop
It is recommended
that the Commission:
1. Receive this
report for information, noting that a minor routing change has been made to
improve service on the 42B CUMMER and 17C BIRCHMOUNT bus routes on McNicoll
Avenue, by extending the routes eastward from the previous bus loop west of
Kennedy Road to a new bus loop east of Kennedy Road, thus allowing connections
between these routes and the 43 KENNEDY bus route, and bringing all-day service
closer to the seniors’ facilities on the east side of Kennedy Road; and
2. Forward this
report to Councillors Del Grande, Lee, and Shiner.
APPROVED
l) Status Report:
Bicycle Racks on New Buses
It is recommended
that the Commission:
1. Receive this
report for information, noting that:
·
Commission staff and representatives from the Toronto
Cycling Committee have evaluated four alternative bicycle rack designs to
select a single design for installation on all new buses;
·
The Sportworks DL2 NP bicycle rack was selected because it
is preferred by the bicycling community, and because it overcomes a technical
concern with the current bike rack; and
·
Contract C32PY04839 (purchase of 360 40-foot low floor
diesel-electric hybrid Orion VII buses) has been amended to include the
installation of these bicycle racks.
2. Forward this
report to the Toronto Cycling Committee and the Pedestrian and Cycling staff in
the City’s Transportation Services Branch.
APPROVED
m) Results of
Consultation – Service Improvements for 2006
It is recommended
that the Commission:
1. Approve the
introduction of the following service changes for a trial period, effective
February 18, 2007, noting that no comments were received in opposition to these
changes:
·
11 BAYVIEW – Revised service north of Sheppard Avenue
·
108 DOWNSVIEW – Revised service via Grandravine Drive
·
311 ISLINGTON – Service on Kipling Avenue
·
124 SUNNYBROOK – Revised service on Lawrence Avenue and
Bayview Avenue
·
96C WILSON – Revised service on Albion Road
2. Forward this
report to the city of Toronto, Councillors Filion, Hall, Jenkins, Mammoliti,
Parker, Perruzza, Shiner, Walker and to the Greater Toronto Transportation
Authority.
APPROVED
n) Customer Input
Regarding Seating Preferences
It is recommended
that the Commission:
1. Approve the
following changes to the forthcoming order of 220 Orion VII buses, based on
input gained from customer research:
·
replace eight forward-facing seats with six inward-facing
(perimeter) seats in the rear section of the bus;
·
provide padded seats throughout the bus;
·
install additional stanchions and stop-request buttons in
the rear section of the bus;
2. Note that:
·
the changes recommended in this report are those which
staff believe can be incorporated into the design of the forthcoming order of
Orion VII buses, but do not necessarily represent the best or final design for
this bus;
·
the TTC’s Vehicle Design staff will continue to do further
work and research aimed at making the Orion VII bus more customer-friendly,
including additional public consultation, pertaining to seating configuration,
styles of seats, design and height of hand-holds, window operation, interior
colours and materials, destination signage, and other design features, for
possible incorporation into the retrofitting of the existing fleet of Orion VII
buses, and into future bus orders and other vehicles such as streetcars;
3. Forward this
report to Transit Windsor, thanking them for loaning buses to the TTC for
research, and for the considerable time and effort they put into making the
necessary arrangements; and
4. Forward this
report to the Canadian Urban Transit Association, the City of Toronto, and the
Greater Toronto Transportation Authority.
APPROVED
CHAIR GIAMBRONE MOVED THAT STAFF BE REQUESTED
TO REPORT BACK ON THE COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH THE STREETCAR FLEET CONVERSION OF
THE SEATING CONFIGURATION AS TESTED ON TEN CLRV STREETCARS, NAMELY ROWS OF 2+1
FORWARD FACING SEATS IN THE REAR SECTION.
THE MOTION BY CHAIR GIAMBRONE CARRIED.
6. STAFF
RESPONSE TO COMMISSION INQUIRY
a) Surface
Vehicle Safety Camera System Rollout Plan
The Commission had
before it a memorandum dated January 31, 2007 from G. Webster, Interim Chief
General Manager entitled, “Surface Vehicle Safety Camera System Rollout Plan.”
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE MEMORANDUM FOR
INFORMATION.
7. CORRESPONDENCE
C-1 Steve Munro
dated October 23, 2006 forwarding comments regarding proposed changes to the
Commission’s Procedural By-law for Commission meetings.
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE
COMMUNICATION FOR INFORMATION.
(SEE REPORT NO. 5E) FOR MINUTE)
C-2 Ulli Watkiss,
City Clerk, City of Toronto, dated December 13, 2006, confirming that Toronto
City Council, at its meeting on December 6, 2006, approved the appointment of
the following Councillors to the Toronto Transit Commission for a term of office
ending December 31, 2008, and until successors are appointed: Councillor
Bussin, Councillor De Baeremaeker, Councillor Giambrone, Councillor Hall,
Councillor Mihevc, Councillor Milczyn, Councillor Perruzza, Councillor
Saundercook and Councillor Thompson.
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE
COMMUNICATION FOR INFORMATION.
C-3 Hamish Wilson, dated January 16, 2007,
forwarding comments concerning the Terms of Reference for the Waterfront West
Streetcar Environmental Assessment.
THE COMMISSION RECEIVED THE
COMMUNICATION FOR INFORMATION.
(SEE REPORT NO. 5C) FOR MINUTE)
8. NEW
BUSINESS
a) Selling of TTC
Memorabilia
The Commission had
before it an e-mail dated January 14, 2007 from Vice-Chair Mihevc suggesting
that the Commission review the possibility of establishing a Shop to sell TTC
memorabilia.
VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC MOVED THAT
STAFF BE REQUESTED TO REPORT BACK ON THIS MATTER.
THE MOTION BY VICE-CHAIR MIHEVC CARRIED.
b) Commissioner
Attendance – 2007 Transit Conferences
The Commission had
before it a staff report entitled, “Commissioner Attendance – 2007 Transit
Conferences.”
THE COMMISSION APPROVED THE
RECOMMENDATION CONTAINED IN THE REPORT, AS LISTED BELOW:
“IT IS RECOMMENDED THAT THE COMMISSION APPROVE
THE FOLLOWING:
1. THAT THE 2007 OPERATING BUDGET INCLUDE A
PROVISION OF $45,000.00 TO COVER TRAVEL AND ACCOMMODATION EXPENSES FOR
COMMISSIONERS TO ATTEND AMERICAN PUBLIC TRANSPORTATION ASSOCIATION (APTA),
CANADIAN URBAN TRANSIT ASSOCIATION (CUTA) AND INTERNATIONAL UNION OF PUBLIC
TRANSPORT (UITP) TRANSIT CONFERENCES TO BE HELD DURING 2007;
2. THAT THIS BUDGETARY PROVISION OF $45,000.00
BE DISTRIBUTED EQUALLY BETWEEN THE NINE COMMISSIONERS; AND
3. THAT THE GENERAL SECRETARY’S OFFICE CANVASS
EACH COMMISSIONER TO DETERMINE THEIR RESPECTIVE PLANS FOR CONFERENCE TRAVEL IN
2007.”
9. SUPPLEMENTARY
AGENDA
a) Customer
Information Systems
It is recommended, in order to allow for
the immediate development and implementation of Core Geographic Information
Systems to be considered in concert with the proposed 2007-2011 Capital
Program, that the Commission:
1. Approve an
amendment to the 2007-2011 Capital Program to authorize this new project in the
amount of $500,000 in 2007;
2. Forward this
report to the City Budget Committee for consideration through the 2007-2011
Capital Budget process; and
3. Note that these
funds will be held in TTC accounts pending City Council approval of the budget
and that a future report will be brought to the Commission outlining the full
cost of this project.
APPROVED
b) TTC Website
Redesign – Update
It is recommended
that the Commission receive this report for information.
RECEIVED
The meeting recessed at 5:30 p.m. and reconvened in
Committee Room 1, Toronto City Hall at 5:45 p.m. The following were present:
A. Giambrone
(Chair), J. Mihevc (Vice-Chair), S. Hall, G. De Baeremaeker, P. Milczyn, S.
Bussin and A. Perruzza (Commissioners), G. Webster (Interim Chief General
Manager), V. Rodo (General Manager – Executive
& General Secretary), R. Cornacchia (Acting General Manager –
Operations), S. Ghaly (Acting Chief Project Manager, Construction), B. Leck
(General Counsel), A. Chocorlan (Manager - Materials & Procurement), M.
Roche (Chief Financial Officer), T. Andrews (Chief Special Constable), S.
Blakey (Executive Director - Human Resources), A. Smith (Acting Chief Marketing
Officer), M. Stambler (Manager – Service Planning), R. Thacker (General
Superintendent, Wheel-Trans), W. Buffett (Assistant General Secretary) and F.
Stanois (Co-ordinator - Secretariat Services) were present.
The meeting
adjourned at 8:20 p.m.